Baca berita tanpa iklan. Gabung Kompas.com+

Apple v Samsung Just The Tip of The Iceberg

Kompas.com - 04/08/2011, 06:24 WIB

"As those patents stand, they would most likely prevent Samsung from providing capacitive multi-touch screens in general, or at the very least any workaround would result in a substantial degradation of the user experience," said Mueller.

"Apple's selection of patents is symptomatic of the problem of patent thickets, meaning that a particular technology can hardly be implemented without infringing on at least some of the relevant patents. The multi-touch user interface has given rise to one incredibly dense patent thicket."

Kimberlee Weatherall, an Australian intellectual property lawyer, blogger and academic, agreed with Mueller. She said while some of the patents in the case related to specific Apple features - such as the way that lists and websites scroll on the iPhone, including the bounce when you get to the bottom - others were far more general and covered most multi-touch gestures used on the screen.

"If that [patent] claim is valid, that would be quite a restriction on the look and feel of an alternative tablet," she said.

What's more, Apple could further delay Samsung's Galaxy Tab 10.1 launch by adding more patents to the list of potential infringements if it is not satisfied that the company has sufficiently modified the device.

Apple could target other competitors

Weatherall said the broad nature of some of the patents in Apple's case means it could sue or demand licensing fees from other tablet and smartphone vendors. It may be targeting Samsung first because it is its biggest threat.

"Perhaps Apple wants to take on one company with the multitouch patent to see if it's valid before taking on other companies," she said, adding it was unclear whether courts would allow such a "broad monopoly" on multitouch.

"Maybe Apple knows that if it takes on one or more of the other smartphone makers, it risks a battle almighty against the combined forces of all the phone manufacturers."

Samsung and Apple are suing each other in nine countries and similar patents are cited in Apple's US case. Apple has also gone after other Google Android competitors including HTC and Motorola.

Google executive chairman Eric Schmidt has previously accused Apple of responding to Android's success with lawsuits rather than innovation. "We have not done anything wrong and these lawsuits are just inspired by our success," he said last month, commenting on Apple's battle with HTC.

Halaman Berikutnya
Halaman:
Video rekomendasi
Video lainnya


Terkini Lainnya

Game PlayStation 'Ghost of Tsushima Director's Cut' Kini Hadir di PC

Game PlayStation "Ghost of Tsushima Director's Cut" Kini Hadir di PC

Game
iPhone dan iPad Bakal Bisa Dikendalikan dengan Pandangan Mata

iPhone dan iPad Bakal Bisa Dikendalikan dengan Pandangan Mata

Gadget
Daftar Harga Gift TikTok Terbaru 2024 dari Termurah hingga Termahal

Daftar Harga Gift TikTok Terbaru 2024 dari Termurah hingga Termahal

e-Business
Membandingkan Harga Internet Starlink dengan ISP Lokal IndiHome, Biznet, dan First Media

Membandingkan Harga Internet Starlink dengan ISP Lokal IndiHome, Biznet, dan First Media

Internet
Smartphone Oppo A60 Dipakai untuk Belah Durian Utuh, Kuat?

Smartphone Oppo A60 Dipakai untuk Belah Durian Utuh, Kuat?

Gadget
Rutinitas CEO Nvidia Jensen Huang, Kerja 14 Jam Sehari dan Banyak Interaksi dengan Karyawan

Rutinitas CEO Nvidia Jensen Huang, Kerja 14 Jam Sehari dan Banyak Interaksi dengan Karyawan

e-Business
Smartphone Meizu 21 Note Meluncur dengan Flyme AIOS, Software AI Buatan Meizu

Smartphone Meizu 21 Note Meluncur dengan Flyme AIOS, Software AI Buatan Meizu

Gadget
Advan Rilis X-Play, Konsol Game Pesaing Steam Deck dan ROG Ally

Advan Rilis X-Play, Konsol Game Pesaing Steam Deck dan ROG Ally

Gadget
5 Besar Vendor Smartphone Indonesia Kuartal I-2024 Versi IDC, Oppo Memimpin

5 Besar Vendor Smartphone Indonesia Kuartal I-2024 Versi IDC, Oppo Memimpin

e-Business
Epic Games Gratiskan 'Dragon Age Inquisition - Game of the Year Edition', Cuma Seminggu

Epic Games Gratiskan "Dragon Age Inquisition - Game of the Year Edition", Cuma Seminggu

Game
Motorola Rilis Moto X50 Ultra, 'Kembaran' Edge 50 Ultra Unggulkan Kamera

Motorola Rilis Moto X50 Ultra, "Kembaran" Edge 50 Ultra Unggulkan Kamera

Gadget
Merger XL Axiata dan Smartfren Kian Menguat, Seberapa Besar Entitas Barunya?

Merger XL Axiata dan Smartfren Kian Menguat, Seberapa Besar Entitas Barunya?

e-Business
Oppo A60 Resmi di Indonesia, HP 'Tahan Banting' Harga Rp 2 Jutaan

Oppo A60 Resmi di Indonesia, HP "Tahan Banting" Harga Rp 2 Jutaan

Gadget
Bos Nvidia Jensen Huang Makin Tajir berkat AI, Sekian Harta Kekayaannya

Bos Nvidia Jensen Huang Makin Tajir berkat AI, Sekian Harta Kekayaannya

e-Business
TWS Oppo Enco Air 4 Pro Meluncur, Baterai Awet 44 Jam

TWS Oppo Enco Air 4 Pro Meluncur, Baterai Awet 44 Jam

Gadget
Baca berita tanpa iklan. Gabung Kompas.com+
Baca berita tanpa iklan. Gabung Kompas.com+
Baca berita tanpa iklan. Gabung Kompas.com+
komentar di artikel lainnya
Baca berita tanpa iklan. Gabung Kompas.com+
Close Ads
Bagikan artikel ini melalui
Oke
Login untuk memaksimalkan pengalaman mengakses Kompas.com